Rough-textured coatings are a popular fad in nonstick cookware, but there’s little to no evidence that they have better nonstick properties. They are considered to be more durable, but we aren’t sure this is the case, either. The most generous estimate is that ceramic nonstick will last for about as long as PTFE, which is estimated to be 1-5 years.
Xtrema may be the safest pan you’ve ever cooked in, with an FDA-approved design free of artificial non-stick surface chemicals. However, the warranty only lasts for ten years as opposed to Gotham Steel’s lifetime guarantee. And with a fully ceramic pot, you might need a little more shattering Cookware Sets insurance. Gotham cookware is undoubtedly durable, and it doesn’t hurt that these pans have a lifetime warranty either way. Ultimately, every non-stick pan is going to wear down with enough use, so it’s good to know you can get a replacement as the coating begins to fade.
The pan body is a little on the thin side and the pans are very light (the 11-inch skillet weighs just 1.6 lbs, which is very light). This isn’t horrible for an all-aluminum pan, but it’s definitely on the thin side. You can also buy from the Gotham Steel online store, but we don’t recommend it. However, this site has a reputation for long lead times on shipping, sometimes several weeks.
The Anolon saute pan was unaffected by our scouring pad abuse test. The fried egg slid off the surface just as effortlessly as it had the first time, prior to scrubbing. Also, you should avoid using metal utensils with nonstick cookware as they can damage the coating. And nonstick cookware gotham steel cookware sets should not be placed in the dishwasher as that may cause the coating to come off. We found the heating performance to be about the same as the rest of the Gotham Steel lines with an encapsulated base. Even with the added induction-compatible base, these pans are very thin.
Connect with Andrew viaemail,LinkedIn, or thePrudent Reviews YouTube channel. Bottom Line — Gotham Steel Cookware is extremely affordable but lacks the durability and performance you get with more expensive brands. The pots and pans have thin walls with poor heat retention.
This cookware brand stands out from other options because it’s made of pure ceramic. If you’re a fan of low and slow cooking methods, in the oven or on the stovetop, you can trust that Xtrema locks in tons of heat with its non-toxic materials. In the value category, the Rachael Ray Cucina set was our second favorite line of cookware. The T-fal set succeeded in separating itself from the other value cookware we tested in resilience and durability. Other pans we tested showed significant performance deterioration after scrubbing with the scouring pad, but the T-fal continued to allow food to slide off the surface easily.
Join our free newsletter to get deal alerts, giveaways, and exclusive content. The Stackmaster Collection boasts a glossy copper-toned exterior. The Cast-Textured Collection has a glossy black or copper-colored exterior. Other collections, such as Pro Hard-Anodized and Stainless Steel, have more heft. The logo is centered on the bottom of the pan, etched into the aluminum.
Food does NOT stick and when washed they are not easily scratched. The Hammered Copper collection makes a beautiful addition to any kitchen. The look tells people that you take cooking seriously, but your wallet won’t take the hit that comes from buying high-end cookware. The copper inspired finish means the patena won’t change over time like traditional copper cookware. Gotham Steel Cookware offers a wide variety of budget-friendly cookware sets. These would make an excellent gift to newlyweds or new students headed off to college.